If you love hard-boiled eggs but hate trying to peel them, you probably jumped for the phone when you saw the Eggies commercial. It offers what seems like the perfect way to make hard-boiled eggs without the worst part of making them – the peeling. But could this really work, or is it all just smoke and mirrors?
Overview
Unless you get it just right, eggs can be a real pain when you try to peel them. The shell can stick to the membrane of the egg, making it really hard to get off, and sometimes you end up having to chip them off piece by piece. This can make it so you don’t feel like making them very often, or you even go as far as avoiding foods you really like because of the chore of peeling the eggs.
Other times they’re stuck on so tightly that it starts to make the egg chunk apart and crumble in your hands. If the eggs are cooked to perfection the shells just slide right off and are relatively easy to peel. But it’s a very small window for success and it’s easy to overcook or undercook hard-boiled eggs and then deal with the peel.
The Claim
The ads for Eggies make it look like the absolute best way to make hard-boiled eggs. By simply cracking a raw egg into the special containers, and then boiling them as usual, you simply untwist it and out pops perfectly cooked, shell-less hard-boiled eggs.
The Hype
There’s not so much hype with this product, the world of eggs is not so glamorous. Either you’re an egg nut and you desperately want this product as soon as you see it, or you don’t really care for hard-boiled eggs and you don’t really care about it much.
The Cost
Eggies follow the classic TV ad pricing and are just $10 plus shipping and handling of $7.99. You get two for the price of one, and unlike many products where you have to pay additional shipping for the second “free” product, you get both shipped for the total price of $17.99.
The Commitment
There isn’t much commitment involved in using Eggies, in fact their basic premise is that they are reducing the level of commitment involved in making hard-boiled eggs. By eliminating the amount of time and hassle involved in peeling the egg, there’s actually less of yourself that needs to be invested in the process.
Evaluation
Be sure to oil your eggies when you use them, with either butter or margarine. This will help with clean up. Also, you can put them on the top rack of your dishwasher to make the process easier. You might find that they can be rather hard to clean, if bits of egg get stuck in its crevices.
Even though they say that Eggies are made with a non-stick material, you’ll still want to take the extra step of keeping them well-greased for best results. Failure to properly oil the containers will result in similar frustrations as those experienced by cooking eggs the traditional way. Bits of egg will stick to the plastic and be rather off-putting. Nearly all negative reviews seem to be from those that did not pre-grease their Eggies.
Does Eggies Really Work?
Eggies performs as shown in the commercials and produces relatively normal-looking and tasting hard-boiled eggs. The cooking time is the same, of course, and since they peel more easily it makes it easier than ever to enjoy things like egg salad sandwiches, and deviled eggs.
Numerous amounts of feedback have come in saying that Eggies work. Follow the instructions that come with the unit and you’ll be all set. Keep in mind that the shape of the egg will be a little off, it’s more like a pyramid shape than an egg shape, but the taste and texture will be the same. Always oil up your Eggies. This can’t be understated.
Our Recommendation
Give Eggies a go! They are priced well, are a genius idea, and the order process does not include any shady things like auto-shipping, or recurring billing to your credit card. You don’t have much to lose, and potentially a whole lot to gain in the form of delicious hard-boiled egg recipes.
EGG
They are awesome, if you grease the inside of them and tighten the top they won’t leak and you can put stuff in them (pepper, cheese, bacon bits etc) making had boiled omelettes essentially. 10/10 would recommend Eggies. Another tip is to use a small spoon to get the eggs out of the Eggie, works like a charm
What a waste! All of the eggies turned on their side and leaked. My bad, I fell for this JOKE!
Mine came with zero instructions and claimed to be nonstick so, as you might have guessed, I didn’t use any oil to grease inside. Huge mess; made ugly bubbly-looking outer surfaces and none shook loose without leaving s million bits of egg residue. I keep meaning to try it again with grease but haven’t yet. Now that my kids are returning to school and packing lunches returns to my busy life, I think I will give them a go. But whoever said regular size eggs are too much must have a different caliber of egg size because even XL sized eggs from local Midwest U.S. stores don’t quite fill mine and they came out looking very dumb as a result. I thought about adding whites from a carton next time to top them off. I really want these to work.
I just received my Eggies, and tried just one. It stuck to the container. I will make sure I grease them first, in future. The only thing that I can warn others of, is that my one egg was a normal sized egg, and it was up to the limit of the container. Large eggs will spill over the top. Beware!
What instructions???? Seems to take a lot longer to cook. Hot and hard to open.
I followed directions to the letter but still had to hand clean every one of these. I won’t use them again for regular hard-boiled eggs. I could see the real benefit if you were just working with the whites of the eggs.
Evidently you haven’t properly researched the different ways to peel a hard-boiled egg. One of the best ways is to put some hard-boiled eggs into a large enough container that you can enclose and then shake fairly vigorously to break up the egg shell and it will also sufficiently separate the shell from the egg making it very easy to remove the egg shell.
Evidently you haven’t properly researched the different ways to peel a hard-boiled egg. One of the best ways is to put some hard-boiled eggs into a large enough container that you can enclose and then shake fairly vigorously to break up the egg shell and it will also sufficiently separate the shell from the egg making it very easy to remove the egg shell.
You get what you pay for, and in this case, I paid for CRAP. They leak, the 4-part design is hard to work with, the threads are cheap plastic and they crossthread and it tears up, if you try to use them you’d better buy a case of Pam because the eggs stick to them like Gorilla Glue! Pure Trash! Don’t wast your money.
worst thing i have ever tried . pain to put together. top does not screw on. leeked water. much easier to bring eggs to boil and shut off and peel.. threw my eggies away
It would be nice if there was a web site you could go to, so you could find out about gasket replacements on the eggie’s. I have one that the gasket was messed up from the factory.
If any one has an e-mail address or phone number I could sure use it.
his is starting to look like just another gadget you play with and throw away?!?!?!?!?!?
I use cooking spray, BUT—-BUT—make sure you use enough, in other words, it would be hard to over spray. My first time out I didn’t use enough and what a mess.
I’m still not sure they are worth it, the prep time and cleanup may out weigh the peeling. If peeled right, using cold water, the peeling is not that bad
Can you use cooking spray to prep the Eggies or does it have to be butter or margarine?
Bought 4. Put the egg in, put in the water as instructed, they turned on their side. Not impressed.
I couldn’t wait to try the Eggies when they arrived. In the summer months I make a lot of salads using hard boiled eggs. The eggies does boil the eggs completely, but the hard part is getting the eggs out in one piece. I even oiled each and every part. Once you get the eggs out of the container, then you have the huge mess of cleaning the eggies container. This was more work than if I would have boiled and peeled the eggs by hand. It’s a waste of money unless you like extra cleaning, then buy them. I wouldn’t recommend it as it adds more work.
WHATS THE BIG DEAL! USE ROOM TEMP. EGGS , PLACE IN BOILING WATER FOR 10 MIN. DUMP OUT HOT H2o FILL W/COLD H2o AND ICE. PEEL UNDER RUNNING WATER.
I hate peeling hard-boiled eggs, especially when I am cooking a lot of them, so this seems to be an ok device for that, but my one question would be, how do they look when you cut them in half for deviled eggs? Also, one more tip: hard-boiling older eggs are a bit easier to peel than the fresher ones, even though I still find it difficult to peel any of them.
What a waste of money prepping these and then cleaning them afterwards. I’m sorry but you can’t be too lazy to peel an egg but have enough time for these. If you want better tasting, easy to peel eggs just put them into a muffin tin and bake them at 350 for about 30 minutes. After baking, you put them into cold water to help cool and peel as soon as cool enough. The eggs are easy to peel and taste creamier.
Always always pre-grease!
If you don’t they can be a nightmare to get the egg out of in one piece and also a nightmare to clean.
The last thing you want to be having to mess around trying to clean these!
For the price they are great, and i’ve not done boiled eggs the same way since i bought these!